CEPR - Center for Economic and Policy Research


En Español

Em Português

Other Languages

Home Publications Blogs CEPR Blog Distress, Not Success

Distress, Not Success

Written by John Schmitt   
Wednesday, 19 January 2011 16:00

On Saturday, the New York Times ran an interesting piece on older workers. According to Bureau of Labor Statistics data cited in the story, the US workforce is a lot older now than it was at the onset of the Great Recession in December 2007. Total employment of workers under the age of 55 is down (way down for 16 to 24 year olds), but the total number of workers age 55 and older is up almost eight percent:

Total employment, by age, 2007-2010

Source: New York Times.

The piece is a good overview of recent developments, but could give readers the misimpression that the labor market is performing well for older workers. In fact, older workers have not been spared in the economic downturn. Indeed, their continued presence in the labor market is more likely a sign of economic stress than of economic success.

For example, despite the rising number of 55-plus workers, the unemployment rate for workers 55 and older is up almost as much as it is for 25 to 54 year olds:

Change in unemployment rate, 2007-2010

Source: Analysis of Bureau of Labor Statistics data.

And older workers are far less likely than younger workers to find a job after a layoff.

But wait, how can both employment and unemployment be up for the same group at the same time? Economists divide the working-age population into three groups: the employed, the unemployed, and those “not in the labor force.” To be employed, a person only has to have worked for at least one hour for pay or profit during the preceding week. To be unemployed, a person must be actively looking for work. Everyone else is “not in the labor force” –including retirees. So, employment and unemployment can increase at the same time if the share “not in the labor force” –such as those in retirement– falls. Which is exactly what has been happening in the Great Recession.

For older workers, the unemployment rate is up, while the employment rate (the employed as a share of the total population) has held steady:

Change in employment rate, 2007-2010

Source: Analysis of Bureau of Labor Statistics data.

But, what looks to be success in the labor market actually reflects the serious setbacks that older workers have experienced in the financial markets. As my colleagues David Rosnick and Dean Baker have demonstrated, many workers nearing retirement have seen theirsavings implode (pdf) with the collapse of house prices and the stock market. Workers who five or ten years ago would have been retired are holding on to their jobs in the wake of these losses. Many of them are continuing to work, as my colleague Hye Jin Rho has documented, despite being in physically demanding jobs.

In this case, there’s a dark cloud behind the silver lining.

This article originally appeared on John Schmitt's blog, No Apparent Motive.

Comments (3)Add Comment
Thanks Mr. Schmitt
written by Doug, January 20, 2011 2:43
I'm a long term unemployed 58 year old and was wondering about this very subject. I appreciate your clarification.
Employed vs really employed
written by Jim L, January 21, 2011 9:45
Great analysis but we should have more of a breakdown to see what is really happening. The one hour a week as employed is pure crap in seeing what is really happening. There should also be stats on the percentage employed over and under 20 hours per week. There has been a great shift (that I've seen and experienced) especially in the over 50 group of going from full time employment to part time with no medical benefits. The part timers in this group many times end up working for little more than their medical bills if that.

A 30 year old may be able to survive without medical insurance for a year or two but the majority of those over 50 not only have pre-existing conditions (insurance companies include almost anything under that name) that greatly increases cost but having no insurance is an invitation to bankruptcy at any moment.
written by Cancer Insurance, January 21, 2011 11:32
This was definitely a useful opiece of information because i will be in that category too soon..

Write comment

(Only one link allowed per comment)

This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comments.


Support this blog, donate
Combined Federal Campaign #79613
budget economy education employment Haiti health care housing inequality jobs labor labor market minimum wage paid family leave poverty recession retirement Social Security taxes unemployment unions wages Wall Street women workers working class

+ All tags